{"schema":"https://www.metamuseum.org/schemas/research-commons-packet/v1","version":1,"packetId":"research-commons-20260814000000","generatedAt":"2026-08-14T00:00:00.000Z","status":"review-packet-ready","question":{"text":"What evidence would be needed to distinguish this fictional demonstration object from a similarly described fictional object?","status":"research-question","answerAuthorized":false},"identity":{"object":{"title":"Fictional study with blue vessel","maker":"Unidentified demonstration maker","dimensions":"40 × 50 cm (fictional)","identifiers":["SAMPLE-OBJECT-001"]},"anchors":["title: Fictional study with blue vessel","maker: Unidentified demonstration maker","dimensions: 40 × 50 cm (fictional)","identifier: SAMPLE-OBJECT-001"],"collisionWarnings":[],"status":"candidate-with-anchors"},"sourcePlan":[{"providerId":"sample-provider","providerName":"Non-executing demonstration provider","endpoint":"/api/providers/sample/search","visibleQuery":"Unidentified demonstration maker Fictional study with blue vessel SAMPLE-OBJECT-001","maximumResults":25,"execution":"human-triggered","automaticallyExecuted":false,"evidenceUse":"candidate discovery only; inspect the cited provider record before using a claim"}],"claims":[{"id":"claim-1","statement":"The sample records SAMPLE-OBJECT-001 solely as a fictional workflow identifier, not as a museum or archival identifier.","evidenceNote":"The cited public page documents the Research Commons method but supplies no historical evidence about this fictional object.","sourceUrl":"https://www.metamuseum.org/research/commons","citationStatus":"cited","certainty":"unreviewed"}],"contradictions":[{"id":"contradiction-1","statement":"The sample intentionally contains no museum record capable of supporting an object identity or historical event.","status":"requires-human-resolution"}],"alternativeHypotheses":[{"id":"alternative-1","statement":"A similarly described fictional object could remain a separate candidate until independent identifiers and source records align.","status":"must-be-tested"}],"researchGaps":["A second independent source is required before elevating the single cited claim.","A human reviewer must decide whether the contradiction changes the claim or object identity.","Prior-art searching and subject-expert judgment are required before any novelty statement."],"novelty":{"status":"human-review-required","automaticallyEstablished":false,"requiredEvidence":["expanded prior-art search","independent subject-expert decision","revision-bound review notes"]},"agentPlan":[{"id":"source-query-planning","description":"Prepare bounded visible queries for registered provider lanes.","state":"proposed","sideEffect":"none","authorizesConclusion":false,"requiresHumanTrigger":false},{"id":"parallel-retrieval","description":"Retrieve only after a human triggers an approved provider search.","state":"proposed","sideEffect":"none","authorizesConclusion":false,"requiresHumanTrigger":true},{"id":"evidence-extraction","description":"Extract candidate quotations with source URLs and uncertainty.","state":"proposed","sideEffect":"none","authorizesConclusion":false,"requiresHumanTrigger":false},{"id":"citation-checking","description":"Check that each material claim resolves to retained evidence.","state":"proposed","sideEffect":"none","authorizesConclusion":false,"requiresHumanTrigger":false},{"id":"identity-collision-warning","description":"Flag weak anchors and record collisions without merging identities.","state":"proposed","sideEffect":"none","authorizesConclusion":false,"requiresHumanTrigger":false},{"id":"contradiction-detection","description":"Surface incompatible assertions for human resolution.","state":"proposed","sideEffect":"none","authorizesConclusion":false,"requiresHumanTrigger":false},{"id":"research-gap-generation","description":"List missing primary evidence and bounded next searches.","state":"proposed","sideEffect":"none","authorizesConclusion":false,"requiresHumanTrigger":false},{"id":"reviewer-packet-assembly","description":"Assemble the versioned evidence packet without contacting reviewers.","state":"proposed","sideEffect":"none","authorizesConclusion":false,"requiresHumanTrigger":false}],"reviewerPacket":{"ready":true,"containsDirectIdentifiers":false,"requiredReviewerActions":["reproduce the source citation","challenge object identity","test the alternative hypothesis","record corrections","make an explicit novelty and limitations decision"]},"publication":{"authorized":false,"status":"human-approval-required"},"boundary":"SYNTHETIC SAMPLE: this packet exists only to reproduce the public schema, canonicalization, and review workflow. It contains no real artwork, person, museum record, provider execution, historical evidence, external review, publication approval, demand, impact, revenue, or income and is permanently ineligible for A+ evidence.","sample":{"synthetic":true,"purpose":"schema and workflow reproduction only","eligibleForAPlusEvidence":false,"eligibleForResearchValidation":false,"eligibleForImpactOrIncomeEvidence":false},"packetSha256":"9ec1f081861455cdcf46786ae081e2b523c4385894cd7652bc8b30dfd31cd0ff"}