Impact summary
The offline blinded-review form now identifies each pair as complete or incomplete
and provides cyclic “next incomplete pair” navigation with focus movement and an
active-step indicator. The eight-dimension rubric, preference, timer, declarations,
privacy boundary, and private JSON export remain unchanged. New v2 Calliope and
Clio assignment receipts bind the improved private forms.
Ranked findings
- High — the task is still intrinsically large: ten pairs require 160 scores,
ten preferences, and ten timed observations; navigation reduces friction but
cannot substitute for independent reviewer labor.
- Medium — local browser verification is constrained: the in-app browser
blocks `file://` navigation, so this pass relies on static accessibility and
end-to-end offline CLI contracts rather than an interactive browser session.
- Medium — draft persistence would increase privacy risk: progress is not
placed in local storage; reviewers must finish a session before export.
Actions
| Owner | Action and acceptance criteria | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Editorial Research | Distribute only the new v2-bound private forms | Public v2 receipt hashes match both forms |
| AI Evaluation | Observe whether navigation reduces missed fields and facilitator rework | Completed responses parse without missing scores/timers |
| Trust | Keep offline/no-network and no-local-storage boundaries | CSP and source assertions remain green |
| Maintainers | Preserve keyboard focus, per-pair status, and mobile layout | Form and CLI integration tests plus production build |
Next-cycle hypothesis
The improved forms reduce incomplete returns and facilitator correction work while
leaving measured reviewer seconds honest. This remains unproven until genuine
reviewers return the v2-bound Calliope or Clio forms.